Will Jews Vote for Trump or Harris? Why It Matters to Israel

Peter Deutsch, a former Jewish Democratic Congressman from Florida, makes a compelling case for his decision to vote for Donald Trump in the 2024 election. Despite his long-standing loyalty to the Democratic Party, he argues that the stakes are too high for Israel and the U.S. to continue under the leadership of the Harris-Biden administration.

Deutsch points to the administration's policies towards Iran, particularly the lifting of sanctions and the resumption of funding, as direct contributors to the rise in threats against both Israel and the U.S. He recalls the peace and strength experienced during Trump's presidency, including the elimination of Qasem Soleimani, the mastermind behind Iran’s terrorist operations, and Trump's withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal, which significantly weakened Iran's ability to fund its terrorist proxies.

Deutsch also addresses Trump’s often-controversial rhetoric and personality, acknowledging that the former president has said things that can be off-putting. However, he emphasizes that Trump's policies and actions—particularly those in support of Israel—speak louder than his words. According to Deutsch, under Trump, the U.S. was stronger, more secure, and better positioned to confront global threats.

The Role of the Jewish Vote

Historically, the Jewish vote has leaned heavily Democratic. However, this election may present a shift. Many Jewish voters are re-evaluating their stance in light of recent geopolitical challenges, particularly those involving Israel. The October 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel has pushed many to reconsider their vote, especially given the perceived weakness in how the current administration has handled threats against Israel.

One crucial point Deutsch raises is the Biden-Harris administration’s softer stance on Iran. Many Jewish voters, like Deutsch, see Iran as an existential threat to Israel, and the reintroduction of funding to Iran's regime under Biden has raised alarm bells. While not all Jewish voters will be swayed, the argument that a strong leader like Trump is needed to counter these threats resonates with many who prioritize Israel's security.

Opposition to Trump Among Jewish Voters

However, there remains a significant contingent of Jewish voters who are wary of Trump. Some argue that Trump's policies, particularly his divisive rhetoric, have contributed to a rise in domestic antisemitism. Others feel that his actions, while supportive of Israel, are part of a larger transactional approach rather than stemming from genuine support for the Jewish people.

Comments from readers reflect this division. Some praise Trump's actions for Israel, while others express concerns about his character, citing issues like the January 6th Capitol riot and his handling of racial and religious tensions within the U.S. One commenter noted that while Trump made significant strides in supporting Israel, his instability as a leader makes them hesitant to support him again.

Will the Jewish vote help Trump defeat Kamala Harris? It's difficult to say. While some Jewish voters, particularly those deeply concerned about Israel’s security, may lean toward Trump, others remain committed to the Democratic Party for domestic policy reasons. However, as Deutsch emphasizes in his blog, for voters who prioritize Israel's survival and strength, Trump presents a more favorable option than Harris.

For Christians who support Israel, Peter Deutsch’s argument highlights an important reflection on leadership—leaders who prioritize Israel's safety and regional stability. Whether Republican or Democrat, it's vital to evaluate not just their words but their actions when it comes to protecting Israel.